Final report on Ireland’s Mother and Baby Homes published

Spread the love


The Final Report of the Commission of Investigation into Mother and Baby Homes was published on January 12 after being submitted to the Irish government on October 30.

Speaking on Tuesday in response to the publication, Taoiseach Micheál Martin, who earlier in the day met virtually with survivors, said:

The final Mother and Baby Homes report describes a dark, shameful chapter of recent Irish history.

The survivors showed great bravery in sharing their stories.

The Government is now focused on a comprehensive implementation of the recommendations in this report. pic.twitter.com/zF904LrvIE


— Micheál Martin (@MichealMartinTD) January 12, 2021

The final report, which can be read in its entirety online, includes fourteen pages of recommendations, a timeline of the existence of Mother and Baby Homes in Ireland, 12 chapters of the social history of Mother and Baby Homes in Ireland, 18 chapters each dedicated to an individual institution, several chapters on “specific issues,” the 190-page report of the Confidential Committee, and the 97-page Archives of the Final Report of the Commission of Investigation into Mother and Baby Homes.

In a statement, the Irish government said on Tuesday: “In publishing the report, the government paid tribute to the former residents of these institutions; acknowledged their courage and thanked them for their testimony. Difficult though this report may be, it is hoped that its pages provide acknowledgement; recognition; truth, and, through this, healing.”

The Irish government says it will now give “very careful and detailed consideration to the report” in the coming weeks in order to develop a “Government Action Plan” spanning eights areas:

  • A Survivor-Centred Approach
    • Development of a Strategic Action Plan and Engagement with Former Residents
    • Immediate Counselling Support
  • Apology
  • Access to Personal Information
    • Information and Tracing Legislation
    • GDPR Right of Access to Commission Records
    • Central repository of institutional records
  • Archives and Databases
    • National Memorial and Records Centre
    • Public Access to Original State Files
    • Expansion of the database
    • Appointment of an archivist
  • Education and Research
    • Second-level Curriculum
    • Research Scholarships
    • Research on Terminology
    • Further Research on Death Registration Records
  • Memorialisation
    • National Memorial
    • Local Memorials
    • Survivor-led annual Commemoration
    • Children’s Fund
  • Restorative Recognition
    • Health Supports
    • Financial Recognition
    • Inheritance Tax
  • Dignified Burial

The Coalition of Mother and Baby Home Survivors responds

The Coalition of Mother and Baby Home Survivors (CMABS) responded to the publication of the final report on Tuesday in a statement: “Survivors of Ireland’s Mother and Baby homes have mixed feelings about the long-overdue final report from the Commission into Mother and Baby Homes. 

“This report is fundamentally incomplete as it ignores the larger issue of the forced separation of single mothers and their babies since the foundation of the state as a matter of official state policy.

“While much of this policy was implemented in Mother and Baby homes, tens of thousands who were born outside the institutions investigated by this inquiry, have been excluded; particularly those who were illegally adopted. The numbers here are staggering as up to 15,000 people may have been illegally adopted by rogue adoption agencies who were allowed free reign back in the day and now have been given a free pass to escape their criminal behaviour. 

“Every single day, illegally adopted people are giving medical professionals false, misleading, and potentially lethal family medical histories. This Government and Commission has essentially thrown them under a bus and walked away. Equally the County Homes operated directly by the Government have been largely ignored.

“It should be noted that the former Minister for Children stated that some 190,000 passed through the Homes.

“Some of the issues arising out of the Mother and Baby homes have not been dealt with in the Report. The Coalition has been campaigning on behalf of the Survivors of the Mother and Baby Homes for many years. The report, which is truly shocking, vindicates the position we have taken, states inter alia that there is ‘strong evidence of physical and emotional abuse.’ That women were made to scrub floors and stairs and treated as slave labour and were also treated appallingly while in childbirth by denial of Doctors, medical equipment, and painkilling drugs.

“It is clear from the Report that the Mothers and Children in the Homes suffered gross breaches of their Human Rights; in fact, what occurred was downright criminal.

“What happened in the Homes was not a ‘massive societal failure’ as Minister O’Gorman wants us to believe, nor is it explained by ‘misogyny’ as the Minister and an Taoiseach also wants to believe. That, with respect, is a ‘cop-out.’

“What occurred was but an aspect of the newly established State which was profoundly anti-women both in its laws and in its culture and out of which emerged the Mother and Baby Homes. While it was wrong for families and others to send vulnerable unmarried pregnant girls to be incarcerated in Mother and Baby Homes, the Homes were handsomely paid by the taxpayers of Ireland and the nuns and Protestant women who administered them on behalf of the state were not entitled to deprive the young girls of their legal and Constitutional rights and the right to be treated with dignity and respect.

“We must not overlook the fact that the Government and the Roman Catholic Church and Protestant churches ran the Homes together hand in glove. What they did represents a damming indictment of Church and State. They jointly bear legal responsibility for the ill-treatment and abuse and the gross breach of Human Rights that occurred in the Homes, Catholic and Protestant alike.

“It is important to note that not all the homes were Catholic – particularly the Bethany Home and the Church of Ireland Magdalene Home (later renamed Denny House which was a Mother and Baby home). The former was run by Protestant evangelicals on behalf of all the Protestant churches, while the Church of Ireland ran the latter.

“We now call on the Government to honour the commitments they have recently given to the Survivors including enhanced medical cards and the long-overdue funds for memorials for our crib mates who did not survive (promised by Minister O’Reilly in 2015).”

In the wake of the publication of the final report, it emerged late in the day on Tuesday that Wednesday’s front page of The Irish Examiner newspaper would feature all the victims of the Bessborough Mother and Baby Home:

The Irish Examiner front page tomorrow is dedicated to all the children who died in Bessborough Mother and Baby Home. May they rest in peace. pic.twitter.com/W2wYRfl6dz


— aoife moore. (@aoifegracemoore) January 12, 2021

Taoiseach Micheál Martin said on Tuesday that he will deliver an apology in the Dail Eireann on Wednesday.





Source link

Leave a comment